Myths versus facts
What this site will not say
A few mix-ups official pages go out of their way to unpick, and a few that this site has to unpick about its own photographs.
Myth: We know exactly which modern tree made Baltic amber.
Fact. Official wording is the opposite: there is “no definite conclusion.” It is “not derived from the modern species of Pinus.” An extinct ancestral tree is “probably the only solution.”[source]
Myth: Amber is always found where the trees that made it grew.
Fact. “Most amber did not originate in the place where it was found.” “Most known accumulations of amber are redepositions.”[source]
Myth: There is a single official age at which resin becomes amber.
Fact. Amberization is a continuum. “No single feature identifies at what age along that continuum the substance becomes amber.” Some experts want several million years; others, 40,000 years.[source]
Myth: Lifelike preservation means dinosaur DNA has been recovered from amber.
Fact. Official pages describe “amazing life-like fidelity of preservation” of form, through fixation and dehydration. They do not say that dinosaur DNA has been recovered. This site does not either.[source]
Myth: The Yantarnyi Middle Eocene label is a date for all Baltic amber.
Fact. That label stays with the labelled Yantarnyi specimens on this site. It is not used as a universal Baltic date.
Myth: The copal photograph on this site is from Zanzibar.
Fact. AMNH holds Zanzibar copal as a collection. The photograph here has no provenance in its file, and is captioned that way.
Myth: The AMNH Miocene wording is a date for every Dominican still on this site.
Fact. That wording describes the museum’s collection. Photograph captions follow their files, and do not pin the collection age on a still that does not give one.
Myth: The 40–50 million year caption on the ant still is the same date as the Yantarnyi labels.
Fact. They are different wordings, from different files, and are kept apart.
Myth: Copal and amber are simply two names for the same thing.
Fact. Official pages treat copal as subfossil resin, and amberization as a continuum. They do not collapse the two words into one official substance.[source][source]
Myth: Amber never contains plants or vertebrates, only insects.
Fact. Official pages list plant matter and, more rarely, small vertebrates, as well as insects and spiders.[source]
Myth: The five Cretaceous ages are a complete world list of Cretaceous amber.
Fact. They are published ages for AMNH holdings from Lebanon, Myanmar, Alaska, New Jersey and Alabama — “pre-eminent collections,” not a world inventory.[source]
Myth: This is an official Getty or AMNH site.
Fact. It is a ReallyByte site on the fossils.im hub, independent of both museums.
Enjoyed this amber desk?
No pop-ups. No intrusive advertising. Just interesting stuff. A little support helps the next fossils.im site get built.